The Best Tomatoes to Grow in New York: Insider Tips from an NY Gardener

Tomatoes are one of the most popular vegetables to grow not just in New York but in the entire country. They’re easy to grow, produce a high yield, and can be used in so many different recipes.

There are literally thousands of different tomato varieties out there, but not all of them are well-suited for growing in New York. While tomatoes are relatively easy to grow and take care of, they do have specific needs in terms of climate, soil, and sunlight.

In fact, the type of tomato you grow can make all the difference in the world when it comes to taste, texture, and overall yield. If you’re planning on growing tomatoes in New York, we’ve done some research on the best types to plant.

Before Planting Tomatoes in NY – Read This First

best tomatoes to grow in new york

If you’re planning on growing tomatoes in New York, there are a few things you should know before getting started. First of all, the climate in this area can be tough on tomatoes. They need plenty of sunlight and warmth to thrive, so it’s important to choose a spot in your garden that gets at least six hours of direct sunlight per day.

Additionally, the soil in New York is often very rocky and clay-like, which can make it difficult for tomatoes to get the nutrients they need. To ensure that your plants are getting enough nutrition, we recommend adding some compost or organic matter to the soil before planting.

Understanding your USDA Hardiness Zone is also important when choosing which tomatoes to grow. New York is located in USDA Hardiness Zones 5 – 6, which means that the plants you choose should be able to withstand temperatures as low as -20 degrees Fahrenheit.

The Best Tomatoes for Growing in New York

When it comes to tomatoes, there are endless varieties to choose from. But if you’re looking for the best tomatoes for growing in New York, you’ll want to focus on varieties that are well-suited to the climate and growing conditions.

1) Brandywine Tomatoes

There’s nothing quite like a freshly picked tomato, still warm from the sun. And if you’re lucky enough to live in New York, you have access to some of the best tomatoes for growing in your own backyard.

One of the most popular varieties is the Brandywine tomato. These heirloom tomatoes are large and round, with a deep red color and a sweet, juicy flavor. They’re perfect for slicing and adding to salads or sandwiches.

Planting Brandywine in New York is perfect because they’re one of the few varieties that can tolerate cooler temperatures. They can also withstand some frost, making them a good choice for gardeners in USDA Hardiness Zones 5and 6.

Brandywine is one of the hardiest and easiest to grow out of all the heirloom varieties. They’re also relatively disease-resistant, so you don’t have to worry about them getting sick.

2) Early Girl Tomatoes

best tomatoes to grow in new york

If you’re looking for a tomato that will produce a high yield, Early Girl is the variety for you. These determinate tomatoes are compact and grow to be about two feet tall. They produce fruit early in the season and continue bearing fruit until the first frost.

With a 50-day maturity, Early Girl is one of the earliest varieties of tomatoes. They’re perfect for gardeners who want to harvest their crops early in the season.

Early Girl tomatoes are well-suited for growing in New York because they can withstand cooler temperatures and some frost. However, they do require a lot of sunlight, so make sure to choose a spot in your garden that gets at least six hours of direct sunlight per day.

3) Grape Tomatoes

Grape tomatoes are a variety of tomato that is small and round, with a deep red color. They are sweet and juicy, making them a favorite for snacks and salads.

This variety is well suited for growing in New York, as they are tolerant of both heat and cold. However, they can be susceptible to diseases such as blight, so it’s one thing to keep an eye out for.

Gardeners may also find that pests such as aphids are attracted to grape tomatoes. To avoid these problems, it is important to keep the plants well-watered and to inspect them regularly for signs of pests or disease. With proper care, grape tomatoes can be a delicious and bountiful addition to any New York garden.

4) Beefsteak Tomatoes

best tomatoes to grow in new york

This low-maintenance vegetable is perfect for the New York gardener.

Beefsteak tomatoes are one of the most popular varieties of tomatoes. They are large, round, and red, with juicy flesh that is perfect for slicing. But what sets them apart is that this variety is ideal for vertical gardening. Given that space can be limited in New York, this makes them a perfect choice for those looking to make the most of their garden.

Some tomato varieties thrive in the ground, but beefsteak tomatoes can be flexible. They can be grown in pots, hanging baskets, or even upside down. All you need is a sunny spot and some good-quality soil.

5) Celebrity Tomatoes

This variety was developed by the University of New York and is well-suited for the state’s climate.

However, bear in mind that this type of tomato doesn’t do well in the shade. Picking the right spot for your plants is crucial if you want them to thrive.

Celebrity tomatoes are a good choice for New York gardeners because they’re resistant to many of the common diseases that affect other varieties. Although birds and rodents may be attracted to the leaves, the fruit is usually safe from pests.

6) Cherry Tomatoes

They’re probably the most popular type of tomato, and for a good reason.

Cherry tomatoes are small, round, and red, with a sweet flavor that makes them perfect for snacking. They can also be used in salads or as a garnish.

Not to be confused with grape tomatoes, cherry tomatoes are a distinct variety. They’re usually slightly smaller and have a more intense flavor.

Best tomatoes to grow in New York: Final Thoughts

Summer in New York wouldn’t be complete without homegrown tomatoes. There’s nothing quite like picking a ripe tomato off the vine, still warm from the sun.

Although New York’s climate can be challenging for growers, you can enjoy a bountiful harvest of delicious tomatoes straight from your garden with the right type and plenty of care.

Related article: Best Shrubs For New York